Do away with blanket radiation checks on rice?

November 5, 2017

Recent lack of tainted Fukushima rice raises doubts about blanket radiation checks

https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2017/11/05/national/blanket-radiation-checks-fukushima-rice-debate/#.WgC6EnaDOos

JIJI

FUKUSHIMA – The blanket radiation checks conducted on rice grown in meltdown-hit Fukushima Prefecture have recently come under debate because none with radiation levels exceeding the safety limit has been found in recent years.

Some residents, including rice producers, want to continue the current system because there are consumers who still shun Fukushima produce. But conducting the checks is costly and requires a lot of manpower.

The Fukushima Prefectural Government hopes to make a decision by year-end on whether to alter the radiation checks starting with next year’s crop, officials said.

The blanket checks were introduced after many parts of the prefecture were tainted by radioactive fallout released by the March 2011 triple core meltdown at the tsunami-hit Fukushima No. 1 power plant, managed by Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings Inc.

The rice is checked bag by bag before shipment, with the safety threshold set at 100 becquerels per kilogram. Bags that pass inspection get certification labels before entering the distribution channels.

According to Fukushima officials, the rice harvested last year and checked for radiation by the end of September came to 10.26 million bags. To cover the inspection expenses, the prefectural government collects ¥5 billion from Tepco each year. Some ¥500 million to ¥600 million in personnel expenses are covered by state subsidies.

The prefecture checked 53.13 million bags of rice for radiation between 2012 and 2016 at a total cost of ¥30.5 billion. The blanket check system began with the 867 bags from the 2012 harvest, which turned up 71 bags with excess radiation.

No tainted bags of rice were found between 2014 and 2016.

As of Oct. 25, radiation levels stood below the minimum detectable level of 25 becquerels for 99.99 percent of the 2016 rice that underwent the checks. The absence of tainted rice has led some people to start questioning the blanket checks. One critic said continuing the system might have the unintended effect of fueling consumer concern about Fukushima rice.

To address the issue, the prefecture organized a group consisting of people from agricultural and consumer groups in July and asked it to study the checks based on the opinions of more than 300 farmers and seven wholesalers in the Tokyo metropolitan area. It will also conduct an online survey of 2,000 consumers nationwide.

Hisao Tomita, a farmer working in the city of Fukushima, called for continuing the blanket check system even though it is burdensome for producers as well.

As long as Fukushima rice is affected by negative rumors, radiation checks should be maintained even if they have to be scaled back, he said.

November 5, 2017

Blanket radiation checks on Fukushima rice under debate

https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2017/11/05/national/blanket-radiation-checks-fukushima-rice-debate/#.Wf8l6HaDOos

JIJI

FUKUSHIMA – Blanket radiation checks on rice produced in nuclear disaster-hit Fukushima Prefecture have come under debate because no rice with radiation exceeding the safety limit has been found in recent years.

Some people, including producers, in the prefecture call for continuing the current system because there are consumers who still avoid Fukushima produce. But the blanket checks are costly and require a lot of manpower.

The prefectural government hopes to decide by year-end whether to change the radiation checks, starting with rice that will be harvested next year, officials said.

The blanket checks were introduced after many parts of the prefecture were contaminated with radioactive substances released because of the 2011 nuclear disaster at Tokyo Electric Power Company Holdings Inc.’s Fukushima No. 1 power plant.

Fukushima rice is put through radiation checks bag by bag before shipment. The safety limit is set at 100 becquerels per 1 kg of rice.

Rice that pass the checks have certification labels attached to the bags before being put through distribution channels.

According to Fukushima officials, the total amount of rice harvested last year and checked by the end of September this year reached 10.26 million bags.

To cover the expenses, the prefectural government collects ¥5 billion from Tepco each year. Some ¥500 million to ¥600 million in personnel expenses are covered with state subsidies.

The prefecture conducted radiation checks on a total of 53.13 million bags of rice harvested between 2012-2016. Total costs reached ¥30.5 billion.

The blanket check system began with the 2012 rice. At that time, 71 of the 867 bags checked exceeded the safety limit. But no such rice was detected at all for the 2014-2016 rice.

As of Oct. 25 this year, radiation levels stood below the minimum detectable level of 25 becquerels for 99.99 percent of the 2016 rice that underwent the checks.

The absence of above-limit rice has led some people to question the blanket check system. The continuance of the system may be making the unintended effect of fueling consumer concern about Fukushima rice, one critic said.

To discuss the fate of the blanket system, the prefecture set up a group with members of agricultural and consumer organizations in July this year.

The group will examine the issue based on opinions from more than 300 local farmers and seven wholesale companies in the Tokyo metropolitan area. It will also conduct an internet survey of 2,000 consumers nationwide.

Hisao Tomita, a farmer working in the city of Fukushima, called for the continuance of the current system even though it is burdensome also to producers.

As long as Fukushima rice is affected by negative rumors, radiation checks should be maintained even if they have to be scaled back, he said.